Steve Hollenbach said:
...... If you slap the side of an empty pipe (and who doesn't from time to time) you get a nice musical note like a bell ringing. That's certainly not what you need for a mount for a telescope.....
Why not?
When using your mount do you hit the pier hard enough to make it ring?
Does the wind blow hard enough to make pier ring and sing?
I know there are people who go to great lengths to make their piers stop ringing, but why? Of course any metallic cylinder will have a resonant frequency, but does this ever affect the stability of a pier? Has anyone ever had an image ruined by a resonating pier?
At the risk of saying the emperor has no clothes, I will answer "No".
If you want to make a stable pier, the most important things are the diameter of the pier, the presence of gussets, and a solid connection to an immovable mass in the ground.
It sure seems like getting into a tither about a pier ringing when you hit it with a hammer is a solution in search of a problem.
Of course any man should be free to choose his goals, I just think that you're tilting at windmills with this one.
dan