Aperture, Brightness Level, and ObservingPosted By Alan French |
Chris Brown's question about a Moon filter reminded me of an interesting comment Harold Hill made in his "A Portfolio of Lunar Drawings."
Mr. Hill started out using a 6.5" reflector, moved up to a 12", and then moved to a 10". Later, he had a chance to use his old 6.5". He writes on page xx '..., I felt positively handicapped by the apparent dimness of the image in the smaller instrument although using magnifications strictly proportionate to those in my present telescope. In fact, I saw nothing like the same amount of detail I had previously been able to record with the 6.5" when it was in my possession. Advancing years may provide some explanation for this, but I have a feeling that, with continued exclusive use of the 6.5", the brightness adaptation which would eventually take place might lead to the recovery, in part, of my previous success with this instrument...it would be an interesting experiment."
Amateurs know that experience increases our ability to see. If we do indeed become used to the brightness level of the instrument we use, it may mean our evaluation of instruments of different sizes is somewhat handicapped. It may also mean that frequent switching between instruments of differing apertures is not the best way to hone our skills. Interesting things to think about during this cloudy spell.
Awaiting clear skies, Alan
Mr. Hill started out using a 6.5" reflector, moved up to a 12", and then moved to a 10". Later, he had a chance to use his old 6.5". He writes on page xx '..., I felt positively handicapped by the apparent dimness of the image in the smaller instrument although using magnifications strictly proportionate to those in my present telescope. In fact, I saw nothing like the same amount of detail I had previously been able to record with the 6.5" when it was in my possession. Advancing years may provide some explanation for this, but I have a feeling that, with continued exclusive use of the 6.5", the brightness adaptation which would eventually take place might lead to the recovery, in part, of my previous success with this instrument...it would be an interesting experiment."
Amateurs know that experience increases our ability to see. If we do indeed become used to the brightness level of the instrument we use, it may mean our evaluation of instruments of different sizes is somewhat handicapped. It may also mean that frequent switching between instruments of differing apertures is not the best way to hone our skills. Interesting things to think about during this cloudy spell.
Awaiting clear skies, Alan