I no more want to jump into the "Dob Debate" than I want to discuss the election. They both may just raise your blood pressure and distract from your real reason you got interested to start with. Its not about the design or the mirror its about the "WoW". A dark clear sky and that sense of wonder you should never forget. Ok, I must admit I am a "gearhead" too. Scope design like everything else is a trade off. So far I have built 3 for myself. None were perfect. If I started another tomorrow it would begin with the lessons I have learned to get the next one just a little closer to what I "think" I want. I can only guess at the trade offs that go into a production scope for the multitude of reasons. At some point the guy has to pay the bills and sell scopes. Sometimes 10% better costs twice as much. Build one for yourself and see who's design and optics are your starting point. When it's all done you will have a better scope or understanding of what is on the market. Then go find a dark sky and get back to "WoW".