The Black Dahlia - A ReviewPosted By Dave Mitsky |
On Friday night, I caught Brian De Palma's new film, The Black Dahlia. The movie is based on James Ellroy's novel about an infamous and grisly unsolved murder that took place in Hollywood in 1947.
For a short while, I thought that The Black Dahlia was destined to be great film noir. However, the movie grows increasing shaky and completely self-destructs in the third act. The denouement is both confusing, although I understood what happened I was at a loss for the motivations of the characters, and overly campy. The relationship of the two cops and the Scarlet Johansson character, who, surprisingly, is not all that good in her role, seemed rather unconvincing to me as well. Apparently, quite a bit of the movie never made it to the final cut.
In short, The Black Dahlia fails to reach the heights of classic crime films like Chinatown and L.A. Confidential*.
The sets and the period look of the film are quite good and there are the usual De Palma Hitchcockian nods, mise en scène, and melodramatic music. Because of the subject matter, this is definitely a movie meant for mature audiences.
The movie is currently pulling only a 30% on the Tomatometer.
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/black_dahlia
* http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Ellroy (see the final paragraph)
Dave Mitsky
For a short while, I thought that The Black Dahlia was destined to be great film noir. However, the movie grows increasing shaky and completely self-destructs in the third act. The denouement is both confusing, although I understood what happened I was at a loss for the motivations of the characters, and overly campy. The relationship of the two cops and the Scarlet Johansson character, who, surprisingly, is not all that good in her role, seemed rather unconvincing to me as well. Apparently, quite a bit of the movie never made it to the final cut.
In short, The Black Dahlia fails to reach the heights of classic crime films like Chinatown and L.A. Confidential*.
The sets and the period look of the film are quite good and there are the usual De Palma Hitchcockian nods, mise en scène, and melodramatic music. Because of the subject matter, this is definitely a movie meant for mature audiences.
The movie is currently pulling only a 30% on the Tomatometer.
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/black_dahlia
* http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Ellroy (see the final paragraph)
Dave Mitsky