Kinda a bad poll in that it's asking for extremes. People in the middle might vote either way, given what they don't want the most. The real choice we seem to have before us is: status quo or some kind of goverment-funded plan to insure the uninsured (and some kind of reform package to keep costs low). The scariest and most volatile idea is that public option.
bob smart said:
I live in Canada where we have universal health care.
My god, I'm shocked you're still alive.
"If you think the country is so unhealthy why don't you go live somewhere else where you get free health care. Europe perhaps?"
Why don't you go there for a visit, or even Canada, and assuming you can find a single living soul, ask people about health care. I've visited (and had these conversations) in: Canada, Denmark, Spain, and Slovakia. What I have found is that people are confident in their health-care systems, and that they don't worry about their futures like we do.
I don't want to go live in these countries, but I do want to learn from them and make our own nation stronger and better.
My best friend is a prominent sports and rehab physician. We used to argue about national health care. I was for it, he was against it. That was before he had long experience as a doctor. He has since visited the UK frequently over the past five years, and he has come around full circle on this issue. In the US, he spends more time each day arguing with insurance reps over treatments he knows are necessary than he does seeing patients and being a doctor. He feels like a paper-pusher. Yet he has no choice. This is the system as it is. He believes that the current system is insane. The system he sees in the UK is flawed, but sane.
Every US presidential candidate, in almost every speech, uses valuable time reiterating that the United States is the greatest country in the world. I find the need to constantly say that kinda funny. Sounds to me like we're trying to convince ourselves of something we don't really believe. The candidates don't spend time reiterating that the cloudless sky is blue, so I guess both ideas are not equally self-evident. Here's my stance: let's make sure that's true. Let's be number one in everything: lowest infant mortality, highest literacy, highest life expectancy, highest satisfaction in life (that honor goes to Denmark), across the board...
That's my two cents. And I agree with Mark, let's talk alternatives. Something that means that I never have to drop my quarters in a jar next to the cash register at a pizza place to help the family of a 10-year-old with leukemia avoid foreclosure.