Image of the day

Captured by
Erwin Forbragd

Horsehead Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

The Cone Nebula

Started by XT8owner, 11/26/2006 04:43AM
Posted 11/26/2006 04:43AM | Edited 11/26/2006 04:45AM Opening Post
Under ideal viewing conditions with 6.1 to 6.5 mag skies Thanksgiving night, I tried and failed again to see the Cone nebula with my 8" dobsonian mounted scope.

My previous attempt was last February at the same location with slightly less than ideal conditions . Both attempts were done with the object at least 45 degrees above the southern horizon.

The scope was calibrated, my eyes were dark adapted, and I used eyepieces of 30x (Pentax XL 40mm with narrowband filter) and 43x (Ultrascopic/Ultima 25mm with 0III filter.) I observed the Christmas Tree cluster for about 45 minutes trying to catch the Cone, with direct and averted vision. The conditions let me easily see the E and F stars in M42 earlier in the evening, and 5 moons around Jupiter later in the night. The scope has an Orion factory primary and an upgraded pyrex secondary and curved secondary mount from Protostar.

In Sue French's Sky and Telescope article, March 2005, she said that she can see the cone without a filter in her 10' dob at 44x. She said a filter brings out slightly more detail.
I thought this object would be possible for me to see with filters, but I guess I needed slightly darker skies.

Has anybody seen this nebula with an 8", or could I have spent my time better observing brighter objects? If you have observed it, what were the conditions and what type of scope did you use?


Posted 12/03/2006 07:42AM #1
IMO, the Cone Nebula is an extremely difficult challenge object. In all my years of DSO observing, I have only seen a few reports of successful visual sightings of the Cone Nebula.

http://observers.org/reports/99.12.30.3.html

On the night of November 24, a fellow ASH member and I were able to make out a very slightly darker area where the Cone is located through his 18" Obsession at a site in West Virginia that approached a seventh magnitude NELM.

However, a MallinCam HYPER video camera produced an unmistakable image of the Cone Nebula through another 18" Obsession that night.

Dave Mitsky

Chance favors the prepared mind.

De gustibus non est disputandum.
Posted 12/03/2006 08:50AM #2
Hello:
I have only seen the Cone Nebula once, with a 12.5" dobsonian on Mauna Kea (9,300 ft). It appeared as a slightly darker triangular patch in the background sky. Even with a narrow band filter, it was VERY hard to see. I recently tried it with a different 12.5" scope, and didn't get it (which isn't surprising since I couldn't see the Horsehead Nebula either, which is quite a bit easier to see). When going for faint nebulae, I look for them in this order:
1) M42
2) Flame Nebula
3) Horsehead Nebula
4) Cone Nebula

If I have a hard time seeing one of these, then I know the next one will be invisible.

Cheers
Mike Connelley