Image of the day

Captured by
Douglas Rollain

M20 Trifid Nebula in LRGBHa

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Where to find it...................

Started by imgary, 10/21/2002 09:47PM
Posted 10/21/2002 09:47PM Opening Post
I want to find a 4.5 inch primary mirror. Not just any run of the mill with 1/4 wave ratings. I want sharp images and the ability to use high powers. Even 1/10 wave will not fit my needs. You guys who know mirrors know what I want. Where do I find this mirror ? Sick of the mass produced junk and what most people think is good. I'm sick of blobs of light instead of airy disks. Don't suggest refractors I already have that but its not what I want. Can't make my own. No where to do it.
Posted 10/22/2002 08:08PM #1
This may also be another reason for a better than good 4.5 inch mirror. If I start with good then I know what to expect. Of all my scopes I had to take someone else's word that they were good. Well I can tell you that's not a good way to get a good one. If the 4.5 excellent mirror does its job I will then have something to base my future purchase on using my own eyes. A 10 inch comparison to a 4.5 inch is not fair but to a degree it is. ANY scope worth its wieght can and will resolve a star to an airy disk "thats the function of the mirror besides gathering light". NOT an airy spot or put another way a blob. Understand, that I understand conditions exist and most of the time those conditions effect optics. I think here that a reflector cannot achieve the same performance as a refractor but could be close !! Thats what I want at least close. My XT8 is close as I can get so far and my homebrew 6 inch f/8. All my fast scopes have blobs for stars and teeny tiny hard to see airy disks even on bright stars. Thats all for now.
Posted 10/23/2002 05:01PM #2
I have to say I have really enjoyed reading and understanding this message thread. Thanks to all that have replied. Its gotten a little off topic now and again but its been fun. Now, let me pose a slightly new question. I undestand that a 4.5 inch scope is not much more than a toy and does'nt seem very important in the scheme of things. But what occurs in one scope can be related directly to in another. Heres the question: Would I have just as good a mirror if it were f/8 and spherical as compared to parabolic ? It seems to me that the parabola in itself introduces problems such as critical aiming, collimation, distortion etc. Whereas the spherical mirror would less likely to introduce those problems. I don't wish to start a whole technical discussion. Bad idea or workable is all I need and perhaps a short conclusion with your reasoning. Of course if you want to write a book thats ok too. Oh and don't worry about the XT10. I'm just gonna kick it to Mars. Along with the Mini Max that won't work either.