Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

WR 134

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

What do you think of Pentax SMC-XW 20mm et Celestr

Started by laurent, 07/30/2005 07:27AM
Posted 07/30/2005 07:27AM Opening Post
What do you think of Pentax SMC-XW 20mm et Celestron Axiom 19 mm (1.25) ?

According to you, is-it justify to spend twice for the Pentax ?

Also, I want to use them in a binoviewer.

Thank you !
Posted 07/30/2005 01:20PM #1
The Pentax XW series occulars are fantastically good. Super coatings, wide well correted field, good colour correction across the field, beautifully sharp. A wonderful eyepiece.

I really wanted them to work in my binoviewer because of their optical excellence. Unfortunately they are physically too large - my nose got in the way. I could not use them in a binoviewer.

Some people do use them in binoviewers, sometimes by removing the eyecups, which in the XW series screw off. However, why buy a superior occular only t remove the eyecup and subject your view to stray light.

I sold my 14mm Pentax XW's, and bought a pair of Televue 14mm Radians. Almost as good, and they work well in a binoviewer. I would have been deliriously happy with the optical properties of the Radians if I hadn't already had a pair of XW's, as it is I wish for an occular with the physical size of the Radians, and the optics of a Pentax XW.

jean bruno said:
Also, I want to use them in a binoviewer.
Posted 07/31/2005 05:17AM #2
XW's are big! For this focal length, have you considered the 19mm Panoptics? I love them in my Denk II binoviewer. 19mm Panoptic is a good cyclop EP as well.

Nat
Santa Fe, NM